Skip to content

Filament types compared: PLA, PETG, ABS, ASA, TPU, PA and PC

Nine common filament types side by side: what each does well, what it asks of your printer and which parts it makes sense for. With one big comparison table.

AMENT Research TeamPublished 9 min read

Short answer

For most everyday work PLA and PETG are enough: PLA is the easiest to print, PETG is tougher and handles heat better. For heat and outdoor use look at ABS and ASA, for flexibility TPU, for wear and toughness nylon (PA), for high heat and impact PC, and for stiffness carbon- or glass-fibre filled filaments. Many of these need an enclosure, a hotter nozzle, dry storage or a hardened nozzle, so check your printer can meet those needs before you choose.

Key takeaways

  • Choose the material for the part's job; the polymer name alone tells you little.
  • PLA and PETG print comfortably on an open printer; ABS, ASA and PA benefit from an enclosure, and PC needs one.
  • Nylon and PC absorb moisture quickly and won't print well unless dried and kept dry.
  • Carbon- and glass-fibre filled filaments are abrasive; a hardened nozzle is essential.
  • Temperatures here are typical ranges; the right value is always in the product's data sheet.

A quick map of filament types

Filaments for FDM printing fall roughly into three groups. First, the everyday materials: PLA, PLA+ and PETG. Second, engineering materials chosen for a specific need: ABS, ASA, TPU, nylon (PA) and PC. Third, composites made by adding fibres to a base polymer: carbon- and glass-fibre filled filaments.

If you're deciding between PLA and PETG, our material selection guide covers that in detail. This post looks at the whole map: when each material makes sense and what it asks of your printer.

Filament comparison chart

Common filament types: typical print conditions and uses (temperatures from the Simplify3D materials guide, typical ranges)
MaterialNozzle °CBed °CEnclosureStrengthWatch out for
PLA190–22045–60Not neededEasy printing, crisp detailLow heat resistance, cracks on impact
PLA+Per makerPer makerNot neededUsually tougher than PLANo standard definition
PETG230–25075–90Not neededTough, better heat and chemical resistanceStringing, can over-bond to some surfaces
ABS220–25095–110RecommendedHeat resistance, easy to post-processWarping, odour; ventilation essential
ASA220–24590–110RecommendedUV and outdoor resistanceWarping, odour; ventilation essential
TPU225–24545–60Not neededFlexibility, shock absorptionSlow printing; direct drive preferred
PA (nylon)225–26570–90RecommendedToughness, wear resistanceAbsorbs moisture very fast; may need an all-metal hotend
PC260–31080–120RequiredHigh heat and impact resistanceAll-metal hotend, demanding, moisture
CF / GF filledPer base polymerPer base polymerPer base polymerStiffness, dimensional stabilityAbrasive; hardened nozzle essential
Typical nozzle temperature rangesSource: Simplify3D materials guide. Always check the product's data sheet.180200220240260280300320°CBed °CPLA190–22045–60PETG230–25075–90ABS220–25095–110ASA220–24590–110TPU225–24545–60PA225–26570–90PC260–31080–120CF-PLA200–23045–60
Typical nozzle temperature ranges, with bed temperatures on the right (Simplify3D materials guide). The CF row is carbon-fibre filled PLA; values change with other base polymers.

The most overlooked columns are the two on the right. A material's properties on paper only help if your printer can print it under the right conditions. PC's heat resistance means little while you're trying to print it on a hotend that can't reach 300 °C.

Qualitative comparison · not measured dataEase ofprintingHeatresistanceToughnessStiffnessOutdoor /UVMoisturetolerancePLAPLA+PETGABSASATPUPAPCCF / GFbasebasebaseFilled dot = more · Base = depends on the carrier polymer
A qualitative comparison of nine materials: a filled dot means more of that property. This is not measured data; real values vary by product and print orientation.

PLA, PLA+ and PETG: the everyday trio

PLA

PLA is the default material for desktop printing. It shrinks little as it cools, often doesn't even need a heated bed, and holds sharp detail well. It likes strong part cooling. Its weakness is heat: it can soften in a car in the sun or next to a warm appliance. It is stiff, but under impact it cracks rather than bends.

PLA is a family in itself. Matte PLA scatters light and hides layer lines; silk PLA gives a glossy, silky surface but is chosen for looks, not strength. Wood- or mineral-filled PLAs offer a different texture, and some wear nozzles faster than usual. “High-speed” PLA is a separate claim, and only means something when backed by measured melt and print data.

PLA+: a label, not a standard

There is no shared definition of PLA+ (or PLA Pro, or Tough PLA). It usually describes a PLA modified with additives that improve impact resistance, but which additive, how much, and how big the difference is all vary between makers. So look past the “PLA+” label to the measured values and test method in the data sheet. It often prints a little hotter than PLA.

PETG

PETG is the bridge between easy printing and real function. It is tougher and more heat-resistant than PLA and still prints on an open printer. In return it tends to string and can bond too strongly to surfaces such as smooth PEI. It is a good default for enclosures, fixtures and parts that will actually be used.

ABS and ASA: heat, outdoor use and ventilation

ABS and ASA are chemical relatives and behave similarly at the printer. Both withstand clearly higher temperatures than PLA; ASA also resists sunlight and weathering, so it replaces ABS for parts that live outdoors.

Their biggest challenge is warping: they shrink as they cool and corners lift off the bed. They need a hot bed, a draught-free space and often an enclosure. Simplify3D recommends an enclosure for ABS; Prusa's material guide treats an enclosure as typically required for ASA too. The general causes of warping are in our troubleshooting guide.

Open frame is fineGood part coolingPLAPLA+PETGTPUEnclosure recommendedVentilate the roomABSASAPAEnclosure requiredA high-temperature hotendPCCF / GF filled: the base polymer's needs + a hardened nozzle
Printer needs by material. Fibre-filled filaments need a hardened nozzle on top of their base polymer's requirements.

TPU: for flexible parts

TPU is a rubber-like flexible material, ideal for seals, bumpers, grips, vibration dampers and protective cases. Its hardness is usually given on the Shore scale; a lower number means a softer material.

That flexibility makes it harder to print. Pushed, the filament wants to buckle, so a short, tightly constrained path between extruder and hotend matters. Simplify3D recommends direct-drive extruders; in a long Bowden tube TPU can jam. Print slowly, reduce retraction and keep the filament dry.

The hardness you choose affects printing too. A firmer TPU feeds more easily and can print faster; very soft grades need experience and a suitable extruder. For your first TPU, a mid-hardness product is the easy way to learn both the part and the settings. Infill and wall count decide how much a part flexes as much as the material does.

Nylon (PA) and PC: the engineering end

Nylon is known for toughness and wear resistance: gears, hinges, sliding parts. Its biggest challenge is moisture. PA takes on moisture from the air very fast, and damp nylon gives bubbly, weak, rough parts. Expect poor results unless you dry it and feed it from a dry box throughout the print; the principles are in our storage and drying guide.

PC (polycarbonate) is for parts that need high heat and impact resistance. Its typical nozzle range of 260 to 310 °C means an all-metal hotend, and Simplify3D lists an enclosure as required. It is prone to warping and oozing and absorbs moisture too. In return it makes parts that work where other desktop materials give up.

With both materials, the number on paper and the printed part can differ. Layer bonding, print orientation and moisture content all change the result noticeably. For a critical part, don't decide without testing in real conditions.

Carbon- and glass-fibre filled filaments

Carbon-fibre (CF) and glass-fibre (GF) filled filaments are made by adding short chopped fibres to a base polymer such as PLA, PETG, PA or PC. The fibres make parts stiffer and can improve dimensional stability by reducing shrinkage as the part cools. The surface is usually matte, with less visible layer lines.

  • Nozzle: the fibres are abrasive. A standard brass nozzle wears out quickly; hardened steel or a similar wear-resistant nozzle is essential.
  • Base polymer: print temperature, enclosure and moisture needs come from the base. CF-PLA prints much like PLA; CF-PA brings all of nylon's challenges.
  • Brittleness: stiffer doesn't mean tougher. Fibre-filled parts can break more easily on impact than the unfilled base polymer.
  • Direction: fibres align with the print path, so the part is strong in one direction and weaker between layers.

Which filament for which job

Starting points by application
What the part doesFirst choiceAlternative
Visual prototype, model, figurinePLAMatte or silk PLA
Functional prototype, enclosure, fixturePETGABS, ASA
Outdoors, in the sunASAPETG (short term)
Warm environment, inside a deviceABS, PCPA
Flexible part, seal, bumperTPUTPU in another hardness
Gear, hinge, wearing partPACF-PA
Stiff fixture, bracketCF or GF filledPETG, PA

If you're unsure, print the same part in two materials and test it in real conditions. Whichever material you pick, the spool itself matters too: see our filament quality checklist for diameter consistency, moisture and winding.

At AMENT, the launch focus is the Core family: PLA and PETG. ASA, TPU, PA, PC and carbon- and glass-fibre filled materials sit in the planned Pro family, each with its own requirements and limits. None of them is on sale yet and no measured data has been published; you can see the plan on the materials page.

When you switch materials

  • Purge the nozzle: going from a high-temperature material to PLA, push the old material through fully at the higher temperature, then lower it.
  • Check the surface: not every material likes every build plate; PETG can over-bond to some, while ABS and ASA want a hotter bed.
  • Dry it: before switching to nylon, PC or TPU, dry the filament and feed it from a dry box.
  • Change the profile: temperature, cooling, retraction and speed are material-specific. For the calibration order with a new material, see the print settings guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best filament for beginners?

For most people, PLA. It prints at low temperatures, shrinks little, works without trouble even on an open printer and holds detail well. If your part will face heat or impact, the usual next step is PETG.

What is the difference between PLA and PLA+?

There is no common standard for PLA+. It usually means a PLA modified with additives to improve impact resistance, but the content and the size of the difference vary by maker. Look at the measured values and test method in the data sheet, not the label.

What is the difference between ABS and ASA?

Both print similarly and resist heat better than PLA. ASA also resists sunlight and weathering, so it is preferred for parts that stay outdoors. Both tend to warp, benefit from an enclosure and need good ventilation.

Do I need a special nozzle for carbon fibre filament?

Yes. Carbon and glass fibre are abrasive and wear a standard brass nozzle quickly. Use hardened steel or another wear-resistant nozzle. Temperature and enclosure needs depend on the base polymer.

Which filaments need an enclosed printer?

PLA, PETG and TPU usually print on an open printer. ABS, ASA and nylon benefit clearly from an enclosure, and PC generally needs one. An enclosure does not replace ventilation.

Sources

  1. 1Simplify3D Materials Guide: PLA
  2. 2Simplify3D Materials Guide: PETG
  3. 3Simplify3D Materials Guide: ABS
  4. 4Simplify3D Materials Guide: ASA
  5. 5Simplify3D Materials Guide: Flexible (TPE/TPU)
  6. 6Simplify3D Materials Guide: Nylon
  7. 7Simplify3D Materials Guide: Polycarbonate
  8. 8Simplify3D Materials Guide: Carbon Fiber Filled
  9. 9Filament Material Guide (Prusa Knowledge Base)
  10. 10Azimi et al.: Emissions of Ultrafine Particles and Volatile Organic Compounds from Commercially Available Desktop 3D Printers with Multiple Filaments (Environmental Science & Technology, 2016)

Hear about AMENT filaments first

Our filaments are pre-launch. Be the first to know when measured technical data is published.